
On June 16th of 2008, one of the most disturbing examples of what sociologists call the Bystander Effect, took place on a country road-side in California. Twenty-seven-year-old Sergio Aguiar began to beat his two-year-old son, claiming that “he had to get the demons out”. He continued to do so, and eventually caught the attention of fellow drivers, who stopped their cars and called out to him - but never intervened. By the end of the night, a group of random bystanders, including a fire-chief, watched Aguiar stomp his son to death for about 45 minutes.
Obviously, the Bystander Effect isn’t one of the human mind’s greatest productions. It continues to be a lesson that we never seem to learn from. The Aguiar case happened in 2008, but before that there was the Kitty Genovese case, and in recent years, a couple more. And it doesn’t always have to be as dramatic as that. You see the Bystander Effect everyday in heavily populated places like New York City, where people have been recorded to literally step over the bodies of homeless people.
Why does this happen? Seeing something as shocking as a child being stomped should illicit dramatic responses, shouldn’t it? As it turns out, there are a couple of unfortunate loop holes in the human mind. One possible cause of the Bystander Effect, is our defense to over-stimulation. When you’re walking around a very big city, there are so many different things to pay attention to. There are people all around you, cars, noises, all kinds of lights, advertisements, etc. It’s a big competition for your attention; your brain would pretty much overload if it attempted to take it all in. So what ends up happening, is that you unknowingly create a bubble over yourself. You end up missing lots of little things, in order to keep your eye on the bigger picture. There is just too much information for you to process.
Another possible explanation is social influence. When faced with a stressful situation, we subconsciously and very quickly take in the reactions of the people around us. If they are calm and passive, we mimic them. This dates back to primitive times when we depended on nonverbal cues like these to tell when danger was near. Social influence is an old habit that’s become destructive today. Most muggings, rapes, robberies, and assaults happen in public places - social influence is a possible reason that these happenings go uninterrupted.